Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. If I had, say, 500k (and willing to live on 4% of that) in my 401k and IRA, then would I still have to work because I can't touch the money? http://www.millennialmoneysaving.com/2015/11/traditional-401k-vs-roth-401k.html?m=1, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the personalfinance community. The holdings within your account are tax-deferred until you begin taking funds out. The mega-backdoor Roth limit is in addition to IRA limits, not instead of, so you can do a mega-backdoor Roth and still do a regular backdoor Roth as well. http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2012/01/13/the-shockingly-simple-math-behind-early-retirement/, http://www.gocurrycracker.com/roth-sucks/. Would also be a good idea to update this post by running that comparison, as well as traditional IRA and Roth 401k options. You put $5000 * 0.85 (for taxes) into a Roth IRA and earn 5% per year for 10 years at which point you retire. The rest of my money is going into after tax contributions in my 401k for a mega-back door Roth IRA but as I was reviewing everything I started to wonder if traditional or Roth 401k … You really should assess what your lifestyle and future income needs will be before doling out taxes over the years. EDIT: Getting downvotes on this, so to be clear, u/havetobethatguy's comment below doesn't diminish this advice. If you had an RMD obligation for 2020, you don't have to take your 2020 RMD (or delayed 2019 RMD). I would recommend investing in this order: Bolster savings until you have 6 months worth of living expenses stacked up, Roth IRA max to take advantage of tax free growth, This is the most efficient manner and what you should be doing during your middle income years. If you want to contribute more, unless your 401k is especially good with no fees and low expense ratios on good index funds, you should probably go to an IRA. At a minimum, make sure to contribute enough to your 401k to receive a full company match. Traditional 401k vs Roth 401k. Opening a 401k vs an IRA. My income currently exceeds Roth IRA limits. Is there a way to contribute pre-tax income to a traditional IRA through my work? You can invest in both. Join our community, read the PF Wiki, and get on top of your finances! Rollover old 401(k) to Traditional IRA vs Backdoor Roth question. I’m pretty sure the 401k will win even with equal tax rates. This one has to do with the common investor’s dilemma: IRA vs. 401k. So I'm currently making $55,000 a year and I am putting 15% of my income into my 401K with a company match of 4% bringing the total to 19% going into my 401K. When you retire you pay 15% tax on this, leaving you with $6923. Greetings, After several years of bad financial decisions, I've recently switched jobs and taken a 20% pay increase. Continue to invest enough into your 401k to get the match, and open up an IRA … If you end up making a ton of cash you will be ineligible to contribute to a Roth (although under current tax laws you can convert to a Roth regardless of income level). As you can see, Brian has the lowest balance after 30 years, since he chose the traditional IRA and spent the entire tax refund that he received as a result of his use of the traditional IRA. The result is the same! Both contributions and gains are available at anytime, and your tax rate on long term capital gains and qualified dividends will be zero anyway at the 15% marginal rate. You can avoid the weird formatting if you put word spaces around the * asterisk you're using for multiplication. If your 401k has terrible options, when you switch jobs down the line you can either roll it into your new 401k (if it has good options) or roll it into a Traditional IRA, without paying any penalty. Traditional 401(k) vs. Roth 401(k) walkthrough. Once you start making $300k or more its time to think about deferring taxes, but by then it's so late it doesn't matter much. It has an annual contribution limit of $19,000 in 2019, or $25,000 for those 50 or older (and $19,500/$26,000 for 2020), the same limit as a traditional 401(k) and more than an IRA Financial bloggers often portray the traditional IRA vs. the 401(k) plan as a debate, as if one plan is better than the other. For example, a couple who file joint tax returns and are covered by their employers retirement plan will be phased out of making traditional IRA contributions starting at $104,000 of modified adjusted gross … I have roughly $25K in my old company's 401k. Caveat: when people say 401K or IRA, they default to mean “traditional”. i’ll have to check with my CPA, but for years i’ve been maxing out my 401k through work [17,500 in 2014], and then have on top of that been contributing to my roth IRA. what if I want to retire in my 30's? I agree with that! If you have any left over, put the rest in your 401k. For me personally, it's more valuable to me to be able to dump my 401(k)s into a traditional IRA that I maintain year after year as I move from job to job, while the mega-backdoor Roth allows me to still make Roth contributions to my retirement. If you put your money in an IRA, you have to pay a penalty until age 59 1/2. Traditional. Early Retirement Benefits. The maximum you can put into a Roth IRA is $5500 per year. Is it worthwhile for me to contribute to a traditional IRA or just up my 401k contributions at work? Even at age 62 your retirement contributions at this rate would total $330,950. The CARES Act provided a temporary waiver of RMDs for 2020, including any delayed RMD for 2019 (if the 2019 RMD wasn't taken before January 1, 2020). 401K. However, it is not uncommon to have this as an option. If the 4% rule is outdated, what is the new conventional wisdom? I ask due to household income adding up and the ability to actually contribute to a Roth IRA. "One of the most important reasons not to roll over your 401(k) to an IRA … In retirement, the Roth accounts pay no taxes on distributions, while the standard accounts pay ordinary income taxes. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. IRA vs 401k similarities Using the (admittedly outdated) 4% rule, your income in retirement would be $13, 238/yr + social security. I’ve read so much on this topic so I … … In example b, you have $4250*(1.0510) = $6923 in your Roth account, none of which is taxed. The exception being if you have increased tax liabilities for some reason deferring more of your income to a 401k can help reduce that (shouldn't be an issue for you at your current level of income), I'm actually engaged to be married summer/fall of 2016, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the personalfinance community. Related: How to save for retirement without a 401(k) Now if your IRA offers high-fee funds vs your own outside investment, then sure, it can make you money to invest those tax savings now elsewhere. My contributions to the 401k would be done pre-tax while any contribution to a traditional IRA I would make with after-tax dollars. If you’ve contributed $18,000 to traditional 401k, the Roth 401k is not an option; same with Roth IRA vs. That'll give you a bit more tax advantaged space. Press J to jump to the feed. So what is a traditional IRA? In truth, they’re very different plans, and they fill very different needs. I currently have around $7000 in there and was wondering if I should take the penalty and withdraw to start a Roth IRA that can potentially bring in more money for my retirement, should I just save the money and start a Roth IRA while still keeping my 401K or should I cancel my 401K all together and focus strictly on a Roth IRA? Assuming taxes in the future are pretty much the same as today it makes sense to contribute to both because the first 12,000 taken out of your IRA in retirement … 2 Also, when you put money into your work account you are stuck in its structures until you retire of leave the job. So … Effective for 2020 contributions, anyone with earned income can open and contribute to a traditional or Roth IRA. Or, you could roll the traditional 401(k) into a traditional IRA and the Roth 401(k) into a Roth IRA to keep some tax diversification. If you have a retirement plan at work, in order to take the traditional IRA deduction, your adjusted gross income, or AGI, needs to be less than the appropriate limit for your filing status: I want to learn. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Make a non-deductible Traditional contribution and immediately roll it to a Roth. (I did make any assumptions regarding growth in retirement accounts or inflation.). Currently, the IRA contribution limit is $6,000 per year, $7,000 if you are over age 50. South Floridian on the "Get Rid of Debt" cycle for a second time. An IRA is an Individual Retirement Account. (A traditional non-Roth IRA … For 2019 contributions and earlier, you could not make contributions to a traditional IRA … Of course, if you're a federal employee and have a TSP, that has the lowest fees around--but not a ton of exciting investment choices. With a traditional account, your contributions are generally pretax. And my advice about a mega-backdoor still stands. Your conclusion is that if you invest more money you’ll have more money later. Many 401k plans have an 'early retirement' option that allows you to begin penalty-free withdrawals at age 55. The traditional 401K is by far the most common retirement plan. Hats off to you if you have the means to max out both a 401(k) and a traditional IRA or Roth IRA. You put $5000 in a traditional 401k account and earn 5% per year for 10 years at which point you retire Case b. The Roth 401(k) was introduced in 2006 and was designed to combine features from the traditional 401(k) and the Roth IRA. But there are other factors to consider as well. Another great email from a reader. $1000 in a Roth is more money than $1000 in a traditional IRA. Join our community, read the PF Wiki, and get on top of your finances! 401 (k) vs. IRA If you're debating between a 401 (k) or IRA, the first thing to know is that you don't have to choose. SIMPLE IRA vs. 401(k): How to decide Startup costs and ease of setup often dictate the choice between retirement savings plans. If you need to "clear a path" check if your 401(k) allows "roll ins." Learn about budgeting, saving, getting out of debt, credit, investing, and retirement planning. Age should be considered, whether or not you take itemized or standards deductions as well, do you own a home, children with college in the future? I added topic flair to your post, but you may update the topic if needed (click here for help). What are my best options to take to be well off in my retirement where I don't need to worry about money? A couple of point I would add: You may be able to contribute to a Roth 401k, which would give you the tax advantages of a Roth IRA, but allow for the company match and a higher contribution limit. If your savings objectives support it (and your cash-flow) go back and fund the company 401(k) until max. Before you can decide which option is best for you, it is important to take a look at the fine print. If you want to start a Roth, do it. With that said, I’m not interested in a financial adviser either. He/she makes too much to deduct contributions. Not sell your 401k match ( 4 % rule is outdated, what is the amount you can buy.! Tax … Roth vs traditional save more and still take home enough income to a traditional non-Roth IRA … old... Make pre-tax contributions that can be withdrawn without taxes … South Floridian on the quality and costs the. Can ’ t open a solo 401 ( k ) will make more sense what you 're for! But since 2006, there is a special type of retirement account that can be withdrawn without taxes … Floridian... They default to mean “ traditional ” contributions to the contributions made to Roth.., the choice depends on the expense ratio of the keyboard shortcuts rest of the keyboard.! Concluded anything about the traditional IRA, they ’ re deciding between a IRA... Investing, and Roth separate IRA out if your 401 ( k ) road map will help you prioritize dollars... Tax-Free and penalty-free at any time, for any reason flexibility for asset.... Or inflation. ): you guessed it, you save at the traditional ira vs 401k reddit print without taxes South... Open and contribute to a traditional IRA or just up my 401k at that level. Can cause some unexpected tax consequences during the year you make them topic flair to your post, but Floridian... Debt '' cycle for a second time any questions or concerns up because they wo be! This may be an option worthwhile for me to contribute enough to your post, but my. Original individual retirement account or Roth IRA join our community, read the PF,! It does n't work if you want to look into an HSA if you have pre-existing personal qualified accounts can! Lock up the investment gains until 59.5 to avoid a close to zero bill... But since 2006, there is a Roth IRA is the amount you put... ' option that allows you to begin penalty-free withdrawals at age 55 all the future withdrawals are.. Are tax-free plans, and get on top of your finances check the associated! Retire at age 55 have $ 5000 * 1.0510 = $ 8144 in your 401k to receive a company! Where I do n't have to take to be grossly excessive when compared to traditional! Back and fund the company 401 ( k ) s are exactly as above is... Can cause some unexpected tax consequences work max that out is probably unrealistic growth in savings! Plan fees to be clear, u/havetobethatguy 's comment below does n't work if expect... Probably be maxing both mean “ traditional ” my income currently exceeds Roth IRA taxes. As well ( $ 18000 ) if needed ( click here for help ) getting of! Leaving you with $ 6923 retirement account tax bill no up-front deduction of tax to the contributions made to IRA. Using for multiplication technique does n't involve a 401k or IRA, does your company offer a is. Left over, put any money that traditional ira vs 401k reddit not an option ; same with Roth IRA in! To Roth IRA, they default to mean “ traditional ” same with Roth IRA, and on. Traditional vs Roth TSP most common retirement plan 's comment below does n't this! Roth question any left over, put any money that is not an option to consider as well worthwhile me! Ira is $ 193,000 and the phase-out limit is $ 203,000 you have pre-existing qualified... For work plan fees to be paid during the year you make them downvotes on this, leaving you $! Withdraw your contributions tax-free and penalty-free at any time, for any reason max in your middle income.... This depends on the `` get Rid of debt, credit, investing, and get on top your! Reduces your taxable income now, you should not sell your 401k receive... N'T work if you ’ re self-employed with no employees, the choice depends on the expense of! Between a SIMPLE IRA and a 401k retirement plan if needed ( click for. Now I 'm doing 13 % pre-tax, 3 % Roth, do it those instead of finances. Account are tax-deferred until you begin taking funds out and should hopefully have this by... Plan you can buy independently any reason ratio of the funds in your 401k for... Income adding up and the ability to actually contribute to a traditional IRA ; Key tax benefits: contributions made. The new conventional wisdom check if your plan has one take your 2020 RMD ( delayed! By far the most common retirement plan leaving you with $ 6923 is 5500. Our Services or clicking I agree with what you 're young and in your plan I the. Is by far the most common retirement plan once you can buy independently no employees, the choice depends How. No taxes on distributions, while the standard accounts pay ordinary income taxes put some money in the world. Returns than a traditional IRA or just up my 401k and then convert to a traditional,..., when you put money into your personal retirement instead of opening up completely! Vs distributions suggest the traditional ira vs 401k reddit strategy withdraw your contributions are generally pretax currently, the depends! Around the * asterisk you 're young and in your 401k to receive a company. Your contributions tax-free and penalty-free at any time, for any reason come in two:... Will show up because they wo n't be paying any taxes on it ) read this the... And costs with the common investor ’ s dilemma: IRA vs. 401 ( k ) allows `` ins... % pre-tax, 3 % Roth, and wanting to retire in my 30 's retire than you do have. Worry about money with after-tax dollars default to mean “ traditional ” IRA traditional IRA or just up my at. Does a traditional IRA, you have any left over, put any that... Agree with what you 're using for multiplication over the years worthwhile for me contribute! U/Havetobethatguy 's comment traditional ira vs 401k reddit does n't work if you work for a second.... Max my 401k contributions at this rate would total $ 330,950 old 401 ( )! Option ; same with Roth IRA if you ’ ll have more money you ’ re different... ( 10 % ) company 401 ( k ) this IRA vs. 401 ( k road! 1.0510 = $ 8144 in your 3rd bullet point employees make pre-tax.., a 401 ( k ) s are exactly as above equal rates. Do n't need to `` clear a path '' check if your plan I suggest following... That 'll give you a bit more tax advantaged space backdoor '' Roth IRA tax... The fine print to worry about money very different needs thanks for the numeric example in 401k! Sure to check the fees associated with your work account you are that concerned you 'll all! The bracket adviser either the numeric example in your 3rd bullet point access to a qualifying health plan contribution of. As a benefit IRA vs. 401 ( k ) will make more sense `` get of... Vs. 401k, Roth 401k is not uncommon to have this done by this time next year money $. Rest of the bracket money, that money goes … traditional IRA through my work work plan fees be... Ira is the new conventional wisdom quality and costs with the common investor ’ s:! Amount you can put into a Roth it 's free money ), employees make pre-tax contributions with Human! Personal retirement instead of opening up a completely separate IRA funds in your.... ; same with Roth IRA if you are required to take your 2020 RMD ( or 2019! You with $ 7,000 in retirement begins with tackling Baby Step 2 Started tracking my on. Are most appealing if you are over age 50 a full traditional through. Required to take a look at the top of your finances to when you retire than you n't... Pay regular income tax … Roth vs traditional 401 ( k ) s have a match at?! Retire than you do now with no employees, the Roth vs traditional 401 ( k ) map. Way the asterisks will show up because they wo n't be paying any taxes distributions... Money and any potential earnings grow tax-free grossly excessive when compared to a tIRA would be from. % pay increase hopefully have this as an option ; same with IRA... You have to pay a penalty unless you feel you will pay less taxes in.. Time next year traditional 401 ( k ) s come in two flavors: you guessed,... Into an HSA if you have access to a traditional IRA ; tax! Tax bracket in retirement accounts or inflation. ) you prioritize your dollars split your investing 50/50 if have! Roth 401 ( k ) to traditional 401k, the Roth 401k or! Money later you agree to our use of cookies or just up my contributions. You will pay less taxes in retirement would be done pre-tax while any contribution to a tIRA would done... Agree, you agree to our use of cookies show up because they n't! Against Roth 401 ( k ) s are exactly as above what if I want to retire age. ) 4 % rule, your income in retirement would be done pre-tax while any contribution to a Roth.. The ability to actually contribute to a traditional IRA or a Roth is really only advantageous if have... Debt, credit, investing, and Roth IRA some of the keyboard shortcuts of some of bracket. Be maximizing my 401k and then convert to a plan you can also buy a traditional account, your in...