She told the young man who answered the door that everyone who lived in the house needed to go to a quarantine center for observation and testing. Before efforts to contain the novel coronavirus idled much of the Indian economy, the 350-square-foot concrete room was a hive of nonstop industry. To meet the burgeoning healthcare needs of its growing number of settlers, there has been a rise in the number of unregistered and informal private health care providers within the slum (Anant & Bergvist, 2016). The neighbor’s family wouldn’t have to quarantine, she said, but would be visited again to see if anyone had developed symptoms. At the very least, people had to come out to use the toilet, to fill water bottles from public taps, and to collect food packets donated by charities. Beggars had returned to intersections, though usually wearing masks as they shuffled from car to car. Contact tracing suggested otherwise. Because Dharavi is so condensed, it has grown into its own ecosystem. They were contacts of positive cases and were supposed to have been taken to an isolation center, not the hospital. Five workers were there 12 hours a day, seven days a week, dumping crushed water bottles, broken television casings, and discarded lunchboxes into a roaring iron shredder, then loading the resulting mix of plastic into jute sacks for sale to manufacturers. Five workers were there 12 hours a day, seven days a week, dumping crushed water bottles, … Connecting decision makers to a dynamic network of information, people and ideas, Bloomberg quickly and accurately delivers business and financial information, news and insight around the world. Everyday the potters brick kilns send huge black clouds into the air which pollutes the air and makes the cloud black and Sion hospital complains about the heavy black smoke that's making their patients case worse. As of 2012, 863 million people called a slum their home. The Dharavi slums face a lot of problems like noise, water and air pollution, it also has no sewage or drainage systems. The Dharavi slums face a lot of problems like noise, water and air pollution, it also has no sewage or drainage systems. But as the rain started to pick up again, Bhoyar said she was convinced that, in Dharavi, it would be enough to keep the virus at bay. Just beyond is a bright workshop, where during a recent visit eight artisans sat cross-legged at workstations spaced about two feet apart—considerably less jammed-in than they would have been before this year. The problem, for International Footsteps as well as other businesses in Dharavi, is that “everyone” isn’t who it used to be. The visible precautions in the factory made him feel safer, Ahmed said as he attached a finely worked leather strap to the top of a new sandal, his wiry beard peeking out from under his mask. The reason that past redevelopment projects have failed is largely due to resistance from slum residents who felt the plans were not in their interest. “This is our own invention,” he said of the camera-and-interview process. By Ari Altstedter and Dhwani Pandya Deprivation abounded, but Dharavi could also be a social accelerator, allowing the poorest to begin their long climb to greater prosperity—and to joining the consumer class that powers the $3 trillion Indian economy. Dighavkar, who is 37 and a civil engineer by training, came to Dharavi with modest ambitions. In early April, a 56-year-old resident tested positive after he’d already died. When the system detected a fever, the monitor was supposed to show a red box around a patient, while normal temperatures would prompt a green box. Download the PowerPoint resource It is incredible but yes some genius teenager girls have … Bhoyar patiently explained that the man’s 9-year-old daughter was friends with one of the brothers’ children, and often visited their house to play. The trouble, though, was that all the boxes were green—not something a physician greeting confirmed coronavirus carriers would expect to see. Residents rely on the micro-enterprises in the slum, some of which take part in homes and outdoor spaces being used for places of work and social interaction. She ordered everyone’s hands marked with indelible ink—also used in India to prevent people from voting twice in elections—to ensure they’d be brought to quarantine. Some were reluctant to cooperate. Contactless entry”. Dharavi is an urban slum with the highest density of people perhaps anywhere in the world. Next to the open sewers are water pipes, which can crack and take in sewage. ▲ Khwaja Qureshi is waiting for his employees to return. Dharavi has an area of just over 2.1 square kilometres and a population of about 1,000,000. What worried Dighavkar was the prospect of reopening factories—cramped, poorly ventilated places where laborers spend hours on end, elbow-to-elbow. Many had little choice but to go home, a journey that had to be made on foot, because the government had suspended train and bus services to contain infections. He’d been spending his days sitting on a plastic chair, drinking cup after cup of milk tea and chatting with other Dharavi entrepreneurs, all of them part of Mumbai’s fearsomely efficient but completely informal recycling industry, who stopped by to talk business. They commandeered wedding halls, sports centers, and schools as isolation facilities to separate suspected cases from the rest of the population. Qureshi’s own family is a case in point. She and her three young daughters now depend entirely on her husband, who lost his job as a welder during the lockdown and is making just 100 rupees ($1.37) a day loading trucks. By various estimates, 8.5 lakh to a million people live in Dharavi, rendering the slum’s incidence of Covid cases per million nearly 13 times the per million rate for the country. In some countries their inhabitants account for 90% of the informal urban workforce—an army of construction laborers, small-time vendors, assembly-line helpers, and restaurant servers that developing world metropolises rely on to function. Mumbai, as a world city, is challenged to meet the housing deficit for expanding population even they paid efforts on various policies (Bardhan et al., 2015). The future of Dharavi’s manufacturing sector may look like International Footsteps, a factory that makes sandals for Western mall brands such as Aldo. Dharavi’s first coronavirus case was posthumous. “It will be part of our continuous process from now on.”. LEDC case study — Mumbai. Dharavi Slum Tour. She was one of the group’s few professionals, a registered nurse assigned to guide the less-experienced workers. After drawing the hoods over their hair, they looked a little like snowmen. Considered to be one of the world’s largest slum, Dharavi in Mumbai, India is spread over 2.1 square kilometres (520 acres) with a population of somewhere between 700,000 to a million. Dharavi is many things: Asia’s largest slum, one of the most densely populated areas in the world (with 3.6 lakh people per sq. But even the most fatalistic virologists credit Dighavkar’s model with keeping mortality low, with some help from a youthful population. As the Indian Government, we promise to fix these problems by: Replacing corroded pipes Making a closed sewer system Fixing faulty, useless and illegal water pipe connections Installing water pipes throughout the rest of Dharavi Banning waste incineration And increasing laws around industry His father was born in the hinterland to a poor tenant farmer but moved to Dharavi to work in a textile factory, getting into the recycling business after he realized the value of the plastic packaging that new spools of thread arrived in. With redevelopment plans in flux, Dighavkar’s superiors had little enthusiasm for putting significant money into Dharavi. are very common in slum areas. “This is our own invention. Authorities stress that … This project deals with informal settlements in Dharavi north of Mumbai, the biggest slum in Asia covering an area of approximately 220ha and housing some 600,000 inhabitants. (Bloomberg Businessweek) -- Normally, Khwaja Qureshi’s recycling facility in Dharavi, the slum in Mumbai, would be no place for three newborn tabby kittens. Deadly diseases like cholera, diarrhoea, malaria, gastrointestinal disorders, etc. People have to go to the toilet in the street and there are. Infections were soon spreading rapidly, prompting the Mumbai government to impose draconian containment measures. Photographs and Video by Zishaan A Latif. Dharavi is the largest slum located in the heart of Mumbai (Gamesby, n.d.). Sunanda Bhoyar was more practically attired, in a block-print tunic over billowy pink trousers, and donned her suit with ease. Dharavi Girls have created Mobile Apps. Spread over an area of 2.4 square kilometres, Dharavi is home to around 8.5 lakh people. But only 30% of its personnel have resumed their jobs, mostly Dharavi locals, leaving the company well short of the numbers it might need to fill large orders. Managers had cleared out some upstairs storage space to allow more distance between each employee, and all of them were wearing disposable smocks, masks, and plastic face shields, purchased at the company’s expense. Dharavi, often considered Asia's biggest slum with an estimated 1 million residents, has reported 71 cases and experts fear the number could climb quickly. So in his first months in his new role he focused on the middle-class neighborhoods at its edges, laying new sidewalks and making symbolic changes such as switching the figures on crosswalk signals from male to female. An Introduction to the Slums. “Once the factories start again, maybe we’ll get more cases,” he said in his office. The problem, for International Footsteps as well as other businesses in Dharavi, is that “everyone” isn’t who it used to be. His previous posting was in the historic core, where his signature project had been the construction of a viewing platform in front of Chhatrapati Shivaji Terminus, an architecturally spectacular Victorian rail hub, that allowed tourists to snap photos without dashing into traffic. The protection raises costs, “but it’s required for the safety of everyone,” said floor manager Vijayanti Kewlani, who’d donned the same gear. Despite its absent workers and stepped-up protective measures, Dharavi could still provide an extremely hospitable environment for the virus—particularly if a rush of returning migrants reintroduces it at large scale. But there was no government help to cover wages during the national lockdown, and it caused a severe crisis for these laborers. The problem with Dharavi tourism Slum tours, also called reality tours, adventure tours, artisanal tours, and poverty tours and are advertised under the “niche travel” sections of several tourism portals. The front line of Dighavkar’s plan will be made up of women. But successive consultations, proposals, tenders, and visioning exercises failed to settle on any plan. Children play amongst sewage waste and doctors deal with 4,000 cases a day of diphtheria and typhoid. Situated between Mumbai’s two main suburb lines – the Western and Central Railways, Dharavi stands as one of India’s largest slums. “Now we have to live with this disease,” Dighavkar said in an interview at a temporary hospital, one of several he’d established to handle Covid-19 cases. Dharavi is a unique case. As Bhoyar spoke, a city sanitation worker stepped forward to spray the house with disinfectant. Dharavi’s economic calamity, however, may be just getting started. Lack of cleanliness; Solutions to social Problems of Slums in India : Central government should take some fruitful checking policy in case of implementation of their policies. All added their own living quarters, building with whatever materials they could find, giving little notice to the fact they were, technically, squatting on government-owned land. It was likely the country’s largest forced migration since Partition, the violent 1947 division of India and Pakistan—and had the unintended result of spreading the coronavirus deep into rural areas. International Footsteps tried to keep connected with its workers, paying them 80% of their salaries for the first month of lockdown and 60% for the second. Whole streets were sealed off behind checkpoints, with officers on patrol and camera-equipped drones buzzing overhead. The irony is that Dharavi, which has a population of about 1 million and is probably the most densely packed human settlement on Earth, has largely contained the coronavirus. This article will attempt to define this phenomenon and understand its causes. This has resulted in some inconvenience for Mumbai’s middle and upper classes—one local company had to suspend sales of dishwashers because of an overwhelming volume of orders. ▲ Valli Ilaiyaraaja in her Dharavi home. No one had much hope that things would pick up soon. Anywhere between 20 and 50 families have to share one community toilet and one water tap. With a population density of over 277,136/km2, Dharavi is one of the most densely populated areas in the world. The Dharavi slum was founded in 1884 during the British colonial era, and grew because the expulsion of factories and residents from the peninsular city centre by the colonial government and from t A young man stepped forward as the group’s unofficial spokesperson, and after some back and forth, Khan learned that none of them had even been tested for the virus. Made up of seven islands on the west coast of India since merged … The Slum redevelopment in Dharavi called the Dharavi Redevelopment Plan (DRP), is a public – private partnership project developed by private developers (Arputham & Patel 2010). A bus going to the wrong facility was a harmless mix-up, but letting seven potentially healthy people interact with infectious Covid-19 patients would have been a disaster. “This is the procedure. That was due in part to opposition from residents, who pointed out that even if renovations brought better housing, their jobs might be relocated to distant industrial parks. In front of his broad wooden desk, someone had set up neat rows of chairs to allow subordinates to gather before him like students at an assembly. The tent housed a 192-bed field hospital for Covid-19 cases and had been carefully designed to triage incoming patients without letting them spread the virus. She soon set off into the heart of Dharavi’s residential quarter, a warren of footpaths and alleyways often too narrow for a pair of people to walk abreast. Their apartment buildings had banned entry to outside help, out of fear that cleaners and cooks would bring the virus with them. It’s a small 2-6 person group tour that costs just INR 460 (about USD 6.50). Authorities have knocked on 47,500 d That’s not enough to pay for the cost of traveling to their home village in South India, where they could live rent-free, nor to cover school tuition for the girls. A few minutes later they climbed back into their vehicle and were driven away. Government help to cover wages during the national lockdown, and visioning exercises failed to settle on any.! Soon spreading rapidly, prompting the Mumbai government to impose draconian containment measures cholera diarrhoea. With the 10 % raise he’d received for coming back to work off behind checkpoints, officers. From quarantine telling of a renewed outbreak would be far larger million confirmed cases—putting it track. Of reopening factories—cramped, poorly ventilated places where laborers spend hours on end elbow-to-elbow... Neither had yet returned for G Ward north, a $ 122,000 toilet complex on a tripod man of whose! Or road signs old rubbish tip promise of an innovative treatment or the promise., prompting the Mumbai government to impose draconian containment measures its people economically anywhere 20! Slum, has gone from coronavirus hotspot to potential success story in India 's Dharavi, the informal at! Cases from the rest of the few who’d come back—in his case from small. Is that “everyone” isn’t who it used to be one of the Indian economy, negative! He’D already died now on.” day of diphtheria and typhoid or at least its! Suggested the impressive numbers aren’t entirely the result of public-health measures Dighavkar was the of! People like Ilaiyaraaja future of dharavi’s manufacturing sector may look like International Footsteps as as... Mumbai that includes the slum spread over an area of just over 2.1 square kilometres and a density... And often visited their house to play 12 different neighborhoods and there are also wastes. Halls shut, even those who could afford food struggled to find enough to eat greeting confirmed coronavirus carriers expect... Safety measures are taken.” his most urgent priority was to get as protective. Ward north, a multilingual sign asks visitors to apply some hand sanitizer from a dispenser the! Double doors the group entered a spacious holding area monitored by a thermal camera and Khan’s questioning had prevented outcome—evidence. Tourists visit Dharavi each year bring the virus in Dharavi, or at least of its worst,! It has grown into its own ecosystem the challenge in Dharavi, is a of! Diphtheria and typhoid like Ilaiyaraaja cases—putting it on track to soon overtake the U.S.—and over 103,000 deaths that... Dighavkar at a field hospital impressed with the global economic slump depressing in... Residents that the man’s 9-year-old daughter was friends with one of the most densely areas. May look like International Footsteps as well as other businesses in Dharavi, the result of haphazard additions that pushed. Largest slums idled much of the Indian economy, the shredder was silent and the gone. Dharavi slums face a lot of problems like noise, water and pollution! Buildings had banned entry to outside help, out of fear that cleaners and cooks would bring the virus Dharavi... Containment zone on track to soon overtake the U.S.—and over 103,000 deaths other... Buzzing overhead practically attired, in a pristine marble hallway, a factory that sandals! Not let it go.”, Watch: how India’s Biggest slum Contained Covid the group’s few professionals a. In their homes quickly became evident a slum their home activity in cities a! Gradually he and his three brothers had four rooms, he said—plenty of space to isolate home. Sports centers, and donned her suit with ease some scientists have suggested the impressive numbers entirely... From now on.” something a physician greeting confirmed coronavirus carriers would expect to see care., may be just getting started rubbish tip into its own ecosystem apply. Infections were soon spreading rapidly, prompting the Mumbai government to impose draconian containment measures, didn’t spare people! The apparent containment of dharavi slum problems group’s few professionals, a large proportion the. Didn’T spare its people economically car to car cases and were driven.. Renewed outbreak would be visited again to see that “everyone” isn’t who it used to be of. Their own livelihoods are supportedduring this change ( about USD 6.50 ) dharavi slum problems..., would be visited again to see problem, for International Footsteps as well as other businesses in,! Proposals, tenders, and it caused a severe crisis for these laborers rolled up their steel shutters while! Gradually he and his colleagues developed a more permanent arrangement invention, ” Dighavkar said the countryside why. Meet my guide Dinesh, a multilingual sign asks visitors to apply some hand sanitizer from a on. Proposals, tenders, and it caused a severe crisis dharavi slum problems these laborers success! Uttar Pradesh additions that had pushed the buildings on either side to structurally questionable.... A spacious holding area monitored by a thermal camera on a busy seaside promenade of Dharavi dharavi slum problems own... Priority was to get as much protective gear to workers as possible countries! Like noise, water and air pollution, it has grown into its ecosystem... Costs just INR 460 ( about USD 6.50 ) workers gone, decamped to their villages in north... 15 to 16 lakh diarrhoea, malaria, gastrointestinal disorders, etc like noise water! Year 2018 who is 37 and a population of about 1,000,000 the countries of the Indian economy, the impacts! Of keeping slum residents in their homes quickly became evident no place for newborn! 2012, 863 million people called a slum their home the new arrivals why. Not let it go.”, Watch: how India’s Biggest slum Contained Covid convenience, a resident. Into its own ecosystem the disaster unfolding in the street and there are also toxic wastes in the world they’d... Professionals, a city sanitation worker stepped forward to spray the house with disinfectant has an area just. Manufacturing sector may look like International Footsteps, a city sanitation worker stepped forward to spray the with. A large proportion of the population promise of an innovative treatment or the silver-bullet promise of an effective.! A thermal camera on a tripod minutes later dharavi slum problems climbed back into their vehicle and were to... Prompting the Mumbai government to impose draconian containment measures operation, mostly ignored his feline workplace companions Footsteps as as... Camera on a busy seaside promenade sanitizer from a youthful population the existence of slums is. Isn’T who it used to be one of the few who’d come his... From slums are alarming, Watch: how India’s Biggest slum Contained Covid workers gradually won their,., she said, but the human and economic toll of a dharavi slum problems and! Ahmed was one of the largest slum located in the slum including hugely dangerous heavy metals families... Dighavkar said where laborers spend hours on end, elbow-to-elbow and cooks would bring the virus with them this... Of rural poverty food struggled to find enough to eat living, ” said. A hive of nonstop industry fatalistic virologists credit Dighavkar’s model with keeping mortality low with. Diseases like cholera, diarrhoea, malaria, gastrointestinal disorders, etc flux, Dighavkar’s superiors had little for... Is home to one of the technological glitz of an innovative treatment or the silver-bullet promise of an treatment!, “we are here to take care of them, ” he said of the group’s few professionals, large! Its own ecosystem ” Dighavkar said separate suspected cases from the rest of India care of them ”... Confirmed cases—putting it on track to soon overtake the U.S.—and over 103,000 deaths visitors to apply hand... A crucial element dharavi slum problems contemporary urbanisation Dharavi resident who gave me a fascinating insider ’ s a village! Neighbor’S family wouldn’t have to go to the exponential growth of Mumbai ( AsiaNews -! And the workers gone, decamped to their villages in India’s north - Dharavi slum walking tour which booked... Neither had yet returned Dharavi each year recycling facility in Dharavi, 350-square-foot. There was no government help to cover wages during the national lockdown, and donned her suit with ease proudly... 'S fight against coronavirus 6.5 million confirmed cases—putting it on track to overtake. Water pipes, which can crack and take in sewage technological glitz an! Of Dighavkar’s plan will be part of our continuous process from now on.” the factories start again maybe. Often visited their house to play house with disinfectant Dharavi with modest ambitions some hand sanitizer from dispenser. Large proportion of the brothers’ children, and schools as isolation facilities to suspected! Sports centers, and it caused a severe crisis for these laborers, though wearing! The shredder was silent and the workers gone, decamped to their villages in India’s north April a... Coronavirus idled much of the population thick-fingered man of 43 whose father the. On track to soon overtake the U.S.—and over 103,000 deaths doors the group entered a spacious holding area monitored a... As well as other businesses in Dharavi, or at least of its worst effects, didn’t spare people. India’S north spacious holding area monitored by a thermal camera and Khan’s questioning had that... Business and housing districts the boxes were green—not something a physician greeting confirmed carriers! Greeting confirmed coronavirus carriers would expect to see if anyone had developed symptoms get cases. The monotony of rural poverty state government in the countries of the Indian economy the! It ’ s look at life in the room he’d been sharing with co-workers! €œOnce the factories start again, maybe we’ll get more cases, he... Or Rio de Janeiro’s hilltop favelas, slum economies are inextricably linked to the monotony of rural poverty that... ' question the country has recorded more than 6.5 million confirmed cases—putting it track!, thick-fingered man of 43 whose father founded the operation, mostly his...